The Fact of My Ignorance

Of all issues in politics, this one is probably most dear to me.  No I’m not talking about healthcare, though that may be a close second, I’m talking about maintaining and improving the quality of our political dialogue.  For those who don’t know, healthcare town hall meetings have been held over the last week all across the country, and small groups of radical protesters have shown up at many of them with the express goal of “shouting down” their elected leaders.

To be clear, I have absolutely no problem with somebody being against the current healthcare bills being developed in congress.  If they’ve researched the issues thoroughly and have cut through the mists of misinformation and still come out thinking its not the best idea for America then more power to them.  I would welcome those people at a healthcare town hall and I would encourage them to go and speak their mind, even forcefully if they feel its appropriate.  But that’s not what this is.  This is just mobs of people screaming slogans and platitudes.  It’s people who are clearly unfamiliar with the content of the healthcare bill chanting things like “read this bill” for half an hour while their elected leader tries in vain to explain to them that they actually have read each and every iteration of the bill.  This news article, after the jump, will give you a picture of what’s going on:

From the St. Petersburg Times:  ”TAMPA – Bitter divisions over reforming America’s health care system exploded Thursday night in Tampa amid cat calls, jeering and shoving at a town hall meeting.

“Tyranny! Tyranny! Tyranny!” dozens of people shouted as U.S. Rep. Kathy Castor struggled to talk about health insurance reforms under consideration in Washington, D.C.

“There is more consensus than there is disagreement when you get right down to it,” Castor offered, immediately drowned out by groans and boos.  She pressed on, mostly unheard among the screams from the audience of more than 200.

“Tell the truth! Tell the truth!”

“Read the bill!”

“Forty-million illegals! Forty million illegals!”

The spectacle at the Children’s Board in Ybor City sounded more like a wrestling cage match than a panel discussion on national policy, and it was just the latest example of a health care meeting disrupted by livid protesters. Similar scenes are likely to be repeated across the country as lawmakers head back to their home districts for the summer recess.

Thursday’s forum/near riot was sponsored by state Rep. Betty Reed, D-Tampa, and the Service Employees International Union, who apparently had hoped to hold something of a pep rally for President Obama’s health care reform proposal.

Instead, hundreds of vocal critics turned out, many of them saying they had been spurred on through the Tampa 912 activist group promoted by conservative radio and television personality Glenn Beck. Others had received e-mails from the Hillsborough Republican party that urged people to speak out against the plan and offered talking points to challenge supporters…

She [Castor] left before the forum ended, which drew more boos. State Rep. Reed said she encouraged Castor to leave because nobody could hear her any way.”

Clearly shouting things like “tyranny!” and “tell the truth!” adds nothing to the debate.  And I’m still scratching my head about the “forty-million illegals” thing.  Are they under the impression that the bill would give free healthcare to illegal immigrants?  Because it specifically denies them healthcare subsidies.

Another important issue is the one brought up at the end of the article.  While some members of congress and certain partisan news organizations are trying to pass this off as a grassroots movement of citizens, it’s become clear that they’re nothing more than an organized group of traveling protesters, moving from town hall to town hall to create a public spectacle.  The conservative organization “Freedomworks” has already taken credit for several of the protests and has proudly posted a video of protesters shouting at a befuddled Arlen Specter, labeling it a “must emulate”.  They’ve also bragged about how their members have driven as much as 4 hours to disrupt town halls in other districts.  And the group “Conservatives for Patient’s Rights” has also admitted to being behind many of the protests, even going so far as providing lists of slogans and phrases for their members to shout out and encouraging people to interrupt and “drown out” their public servants.  Obviously there’s nothing wrong with organized protests, but it does irk me some when they then vehemently deny that they’re anything but regular ole town hall attendees.  Its very reminiscent of the Tea Parties that FoxNews and Freedomworks organized and promoted for months, and then covered as “an inspiring, spontaneous, grassroots call for liberty”.  But more than simply being dishonest, these shipped-in protestors deny the real constituents of that district their opportunity to participate.

To those who may be sympathetic towards these protesters, or who may be warming up their lungs for a town hall appearance of their own, I submit for your consideration this quote from one of our great founding fathers, John Adams:

“I fear that in every assembly, members will obtain an influence by noise not sense. By meanness, not greatness, By ignorance, not learning, By contracted hearts, not large souls.
There is one thing, my dear sir, that must be attempted and most sacredly observed or we are all undone. There must be decency and respect, and veneration introduced for persons of authority of every rank, or we are all undone. in a popular government, this is our only way”
–John Adams, from a letter to one of his constituents.

Is that really too much to ask?  While I was no fan of President Bush’s policies I always cringed when protesters would hold up signs comparing him to hitler, or when I’d hear someone call him an “idiot” or “ignoramous”.  And I cringe now that the tables have turned and it seems that in less than 6 months our country is already more comfortable disrespecting our elected leaders than we were 6 years into the Bush administration.  I mean seriously, when did we get to the point that a very friendly looking man like the one in the picture above feels comfortable being photographed while hanging his congressman in effigy at a town hall meeting?  Certainly this is not the direction our country should be headed in, and its not the kind of political discourse our founding fathers hoped we’d be engaging in 200 years later.  Whether you like your leaders or not, they were elected fairly and justly through the rules of representative democracy.  And whether you feel like their opinions mirror your own or not, to disrespect them to this degree is to disrespect the system laid down by our founding fathers.

Even pushing all that to the side, this kind of incivility is just plain stupid.  These protesters are complaining that their voice isn’t being heard and when they have the opportunity to make their concerns known directly to their elected leaders they opt instead to hurl insults and angry non sequiturs, missing an opportunity to contribute thoughtfully to the discussion and instantly identifying themselves as solution-less obstructionists.  Healthcare reform is an exceptionally complex issue, and the bills going through congress are actually impressively moderate.  There are certainly elements of them that are controversial, but as US Rep Kathy Castor tried to tell her incensed Tampa crowd, “There is more consensus than there is disagreement when you get right down to it”.  I think most people, including conservatives,  would find upon actually studying these bills that there is a lot to like.

So please, lets all calm down and take a deep breath.  If you’re concerned about healthcare reform then get educated using balanced and unbaised sources (this post: Some Basic Info on the House’s Healthcare Reform Bill  will get you started).  Then if you find that once you understand the bills circulating congress you still oppose them then by all means work to modify or even defeat them.  But please do so thoughtfully, with civility, sans fear-mongering and hyperbole, and with a healthy respect for those who disagree, and those your community has chosen to represent you.

Related posts:

1. All About Healthcare Co-ops As the battle for healthcare reform rages on, many of...
2. Obama’s Healthcare Speech Visit msnbc.com for Breaking News, World News, and News about...